Good intentions and personal sacrifice are important. But how can trustees be sure they are doing the right thing?
A statement that concerned me
“We work and take decisions in the best interests of the charity.”
I was recently invited to a trustee meeting in my capacity as a governance specialist to answer questions about advice I had previously given.
During the discussion, a trustee made this statement with complete sincerity. I stopped him and challenged what he had said.
Not because I doubted his intentions, but because I hear this statement regularly, particularly in faith-based charities, and find it concerning.
Acting in a charity’s best interests is not simply about believing you are doing the right thing. You must be able to demonstrate it.
Good intentions are not enough
Charity trustees often give up their time, contribute their own money and make personal sacrifices to support good causes.
In Muslim charities, I regularly hear trustees say they undertake this work to please Allah (SWT), without expecting anything in return. This is admirable and deserves recognition.
However, problems arise when trustees use their good intentions and personal sacrifices to justify their decisions, whether right or wrong.
“Good intentions explain why we serve a charity. Good governance shows whether we are serving it properly.”
A charity’s best interests are not simply what trustees personally believe them to be. They must be guided by the charity’s governing document, charity law and Charity Commission guidance.
This means advancing the charity’s objectives, protecting donor funds, safeguarding beneficiaries, managing risks and protecting its reputation.
A governance failure in one charity can damage public confidence in other charities too.
In Islam, trusteeship is an amanah — a responsibility entrusted to us. Fulfilling that responsibility requires more than sincerity. It requires proper care, accountability and good judgement.
Trusting the CEO is not enough
In smaller charities, trustees are often directly involved in running the organisation. In larger charities, they employ a CEO or management team to deliver the charity’s work.
This brings another common misunderstanding.
Trustees often tell me they have complete confidence in their CEO or manager because they are competent, hardworking and trustworthy. These are important qualities, but trust is not a replacement for proper oversight.
“Trust your CEO, but do not rely on trust alone to protect your charity.”
The ultimate responsibility for the charity remains with the trustees. This responsibility is legal, moral and, for Muslim trustees, religious.
Trustees must ensure suitable policies, financial controls, risk management, staff training and reporting arrangements are in place. Larger charities may also need independent governance reviews and internal audits.
The systems will differ according to the charity’s size, but the responsibility remains the same.
Why this statement makes me uneasy
In my professional work, I regularly deal with governance problems in charities, large and small. The story often repeats itself.
Trustees genuinely believe they are acting in the charity’s interests. They may have made considerable personal sacrifices, yet have failed to follow their governing document, understand their legal duties or put proper controls in place.
When problems arise, they are often surprised that their decisions are being questioned.
This is why I become uneasy when trustees confidently say they act in their charity’s best interests without referring to the rules, evidence and governance standards that should guide them.
Sometimes, I imagine a charity heading towards a governance cliff while its trustees remain confident that everything is going well.
“The danger is not always bad intentions. Sometimes trustees are so confident in their good intentions that they fail to see the risks.”
Five Charity Commission guides every trustee should read
The Charity Commission provides extensive guidance to help trustees fulfil their responsibilities. Regardless of charity size, I consider these five particularly important.
- The Essential Trustee (CC3) – Explains trustees’ main legal duties and responsibilities.
- Decision-making (CC27) – Explains how trustees should make informed and proper decisions.
- Internal Financial Controls (CC8) – Helps protect charitable funds and prevent financial failures.
- Conflicts of Interest (CC29) – Explains how trustees should identify and manage conflicts.
- Risk Management (CC26) – Helps trustees identify and manage risks facing their charity.
These should be essential reading, not documents consulted only when something goes wrong.
Good governance is part of our amanah
I have great respect for trustees who sacrifice their time and money to serve their communities. Most genuinely want to do the right thing.
But sincerity and sacrifice cannot replace knowledge, accountability and good governance.
For Muslim trustees, following charity law and good governance standards should be seen as part of fulfilling their religious responsibilities, not separate from them.
I welcome trustees saying they act in their charity’s best interests. But I would be far more reassured if they could demonstrate how they know this to be true.
“Good intentions bring us into charity work. Good governance helps us fulfil the trust placed in us.”
Ultimately, the question trustees should ask is not simply whether they believe they are acting in the charity’s best interests, but whether they have the evidence to demonstrate it.
That is what responsible trusteeship really means.
Author:
Nasir Rafiq FCA is Managing Partner of Dua Governance, specialising in charity governance, risk management, internal audit and regulatory compliance.
